A note on “Illusion or Ingenuity” article

The article “Illusion or Ingenuity?” has been welcomed by the website readers and now, one of them has pointed some notes and facts about it as below:

The author of the “Illusion or Ingenuity” article, who is apprehensive of the future of the Music in Iran, enumerates some symptoms of the music weakening in the country for example decreasing in the quality of the music as well as lack of the innovation in creating them, a gradual decline in the music public taste and the drop in the application of layered sound and polyphony in music. He explains that one reason for this gradual weakening might be our unawareness of the fact that we are not so intelligent nation. He believes that we, Iranians, have a comprehensive “Illusion of the high national intelligence “that make us ignorant of the unfavorable realities of our music and consequently no searching for the remedy is taking place. His point of view brings to the mind a patient who thinks he is healthy, therefore delays the treatment and finally is killed by the disease. The author also refers to the national difficulties which gradually will lower the national intelligence score such as the increased rate of the immigration and brain drain, low quality of the nutrition, incompetence of the education system and etc and predicts that the condition of the music of Iran might deteriorate in the future because of the mentioned illusion of its great status.

The criticisms and questions raised by the readers of the article were mainly focused on two subjects:
1- Uncertainty about the accuracy of the intelligence quotient (IQ) of Iranians (84) and the validity of the source used for the reported IQ.
2- The involvement of factors other than “not so high IQ” and “Illusion of intelligence” in the enumerated imperfections of the music of Iran.

It is hoped that the following hints, could resolve the uncertainties, answer the raised questions and lead to a fair judgment:
i. The source used in the Yaghoobian’s article for reporting the national IQ score is a website named photius (www.photius.com). The site itself got the information from a 2002 book “IQ and the wealth of the nations “by Richard Lynn, Professor of Psychology, and Tatu Vanhanen, Professor of Political Sciences. The book argues that international differences in current economic development are due in part to differences in average national intelligence as indicated by national IQ estimates. The IQ figures were based on actual tests for IQ in 81 nations including Iran. In 104 of the world’s nations there were no IQ studies at all and the IQ was estimated based on IQ in surrounding nations with similar ethnicities and cultures.
Many other studies have used the data reported in this book, while some criticisms has been raised including the questioning of the methodology and of the incompleteness of the data, as well as of the conclusions of it. In 2006, the authors published another book named “IQ and Global Inequality” presenting calculated IQs for 113 countries and estimated IQs for an additional 79 countries. They also responded to the first book critics.
In 2010, in an article entitled “National IQs updated for 41 Nations”, Lynn presented new national IQs for 25 countries and revised national IQs for 16 countries and there was no change in the IQ score reported for Iran (IQ score 84) (1).
In a 2012 article of Lynn and Vanhanen “National IQs: A review of their educational, cognitive, economic, political, demographic, sociological, epidemiological, geographic and climatic correlates” showed that there are significant and substantial correlations between national IQs and a wide range of phenomena including educational attainment (EA) (represented by scores obtained by school students in math and science), per capita income, economic growth, various other economic variables, crime, political institutions, health, demographic and sociological variables, and geographic and climatic variables. In this way they defended the validity of their reported national IQs and believe that these high correlations would not be present if their national IQs were meaningless (2).
ii. One of the most valid studies designed for large scale and international assessments of teaching and learning in mathematics and science used in the intelligence-focused articles is “TIMSS” (Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study). TIMSS is a project of the International Association for the Evaluation of Educational Achievement (IEA) (3).
First conducted in 1995, TIMSS reports every four years on the educational achievement of Year 4 and Year 8 students of many countries, compares them and provides an international perspective on teaching and learning in mathematics and science. TIMSS scores are scaled to have an international average value of 500 (TIMSS scale centerpoint) and a standard deviation of 100 points(3).
In the article “National IQs calculated and validated for 108 nations” Lynn et al demonstrated that national IQs presented by them have a high degree of validity by proving that there was a high correlation between the educational attainment (EA) scores (obtained by integrating scores from a number of studies i.e. TIMSS) and the national IQs. The correlation of EA with measured IQ (N = 86 countries) was 0.917, and with measured + estimated IQ (N = 108 countries) was o.907 (4).
Fortunately, Iran has participated in all five TIMSS studies in 1995, 1999, 2003, 2007 and 2011 and the average scores of Iranian students in the 2011 study were:
• Average mathematics scores of 4th-grade students: 431
• Average mathematics scores of 8th-grade students: 415
• Average science scores of 4th-grade students: 453
• Average science scores of 8th-grade students: 474

As it is seen, the average scores of Iranian students in both grades are lower than the TIMSS centerpoint (500) (5).

iii. Many scientific studies have proven that intelligence depends on the genetic makeup (Genes and their inheritance) of individual as well as environmental variables (e.g. prenatal and early nutrition, parenting style, home environment, education, experiences, physical activity …). Using the adjectives undeveloped, developing and developed for describing the status of economical growth of the countries, in part represents the quality of environmental factors involved in shaping the intelligence of a nation. Therefore it is not so unexpected that the IQ and EA scores are lower in less developed (undeveloped and developing) countries.
Lynn and Vanhanen who founded the theory: “international differences in current economic and social phenomena are due in part to differences in average national intelligence”, also envisioned that for many of these are positive feedback loops such that, for instance, national IQs are a determinant of per capita income, educational attainment, and health, and these exert a reciprocal causal effect on national IQs(2).
iv. In a 2009 article “Decomposing self-estimates of intelligence: structure and sex differences across 12 nations.” Furnham et al compared the self-estimates of intelligence (SEI) across 12 nations (Australia, Austria, Brazil, France, Iran, Israel, Malaysia, South Africa, Spain, Turkey, UK and US) with the national IQs presented by Lynn and Vanhanen. All 12 nations estimated their IQ higher than that calculated IQs. The highest difference (34 points) only after South Africa belongs to Iranians (Figure 1) (6).


Figure 1: self-estimates of intelligence and national IQ Scores across nations (6).

v. And the last but not the least point: according to the Gardner’s multiple intelligence theory one of the intelligence categories is musical intelligence which describes the ability to understand and process auditory data and sensitivity to the sounds, rhythms, tones, and music (7). Similar to other kinds of intelligence, everyone is thought to possess musical intelligence at some level and this level is affected by genetic and environmental factors. Some people such as great musicians have high degrees of genetic musical intelligence, however it should be considered that everybody ‘s musical intelligence in any level can be enhanced or deteriorated by the impact of positive and negative environmental factors, respectively. Emphasizing on music training in childhood especially in the family, governmental funding for music training, deploying professional and experienced music teachers in music institutes, glorification of good musicians, holding high quality music concerts, using high quality music in visual and audio media and etc … all are examples of environmental factors that could affect musical intelligence. Accordingly as stated by the author of the “Illusion or Ingenuity”, long-term negligence of these critical issues due to the “Illusion of Ingenuity” will undoubtedly deteriorate Iranian music position.
In the hope for a more intelligent Iranian nation

References:
1- Lynn R.; National IQs updated for 41 Nations. Mankind Quarterly, Vol. 50, No. 4, 2010, pp. 275-296.
2- Lynn R., Vanhanen T.; National IQs: A review of their educational, cognitive, economic, political, demographic, sociological, epidemiological, geographic and climatic correlates. Intelligence, Vol. 40, Issue 2, 2012, pp. 226–234.
3-http://www.iea.nl
4- Lynn R., Meisenberg G.; National IQs calculated and validated for 108 nations. Intelligence, Volume 38, Issue 4, 2010, pp. 353–360.
5- nces.ed.gov
6- Von Stumm S., Chamorro-Premuzic T., Furnham A.; Decomposing self-estimates of intelligence: structure and sex differences across 12 nations. Br J Psychol, 2009, 100 (Pt 2), pp. 429-442.
7- Martin G.N., Carlson N. R., Buskist W.; “Intelligence and thinking” in Psychology. Pearson. 5th Edition, 2013.

Post a Comment

Required fields are marked *
*
*
Your email is never shared.

Iranian Fallacies – Composition and Arrangement

In the tradition of classical music, it is generally tried to use the same technical terms related to music in all countries. Even in the cultures in which native terms exist to refer to musical terms, usually the better known universal terms are employed.

A Note on the Occasion of Houshang Zarif’s Demise

No introduction is needed when talking about the position of the late Houshang Zarif (1938-2020) in the Iranian music. His character and personality are so well-known among musicians that his name per se is a symbol and role model for the Iranian youth. “Becoming Houshang Zarif” is the dream of many young people who enter the world of music in Iran and many of whom retire regretting the realisation of this dream.

From Past Days…

Prominent Iranian Musicologist Passes Away in Vienna

Khosrow Djafarzadeh, musicologist and architect, who was also one of the main authors of HarmonyTalk journal passed away on 15 July 2019.

Quality Decline in Regional Music Festivals

Regional music festivals are organized to, firstly, introduce the music of different regions and, secondly, to support its performers. Regional music festivals are held in large cities for various reasons, including the availability of financial and executive facilities and the presence of an audience. However, the organization of these festivals has always been one of the challenging issues of ethnomusicology. The reason is that the presence of regional music performers in large cities places them in a context other than the context they would normally perform in their homes; consequently this change in situation leads to changes in the quality of their performance.

Banan: the Artist of the Age

Gholam Hossein Banan was born in 1911 in Tehran. He was born in an affluent art-loving family who were Naser al-Din Shah Qajar (1848-1896)’s relative. The Qajar King was his mother’s uncle on her father’s side. He learnt his first lessons in music while his father sang Iranian avaz (improvised rhythmic-free singing), he then attended classes by the renowned Iranian composer, Morteza Neydavoud (1900-1990) along with his sisters; the composer is, therefore, considered as his first teacher. He then learnt Iranian avaz under the supervision of Mirza Taher Zia Resaee (Zia-o Zakerin) and Naser Seif in an oral manner.

Harmony in the Iranian Music (I)

Translated by Mahboube Khalvati The article you are about to read was written by Rouhollah Khaleqi (1906-1965), composer, and conductor of Golha Orchestra (established in 1956). Khaleqi was one of the most prominent promoters of polyphony for the Iranian music and is one of the best representatives of the school of Ali Naghi Vaziri. In…
Read More »

Musical Sense or Technique?

One of the most popular terms used by Iranian instrumentalists is the existence or a lack of musical “sense”. Both musicians and fans of music consider having “sense” while playing music as an important principle to the extent that they use it vis-a-vis having technique.

A note on “Illusion or Ingenuity” article

The author of the “Illusion or Ingenuity” article, who is apprehensive of the future of the Music in Iran, enumerates some symptoms of the music weakening in the country for example decreasing in the quality of the music as well as lack of the innovation in creating them, a gradual decline in the music public taste and the drop in the application of layered sound and polyphony in music. He explains that one reason for this gradual weakening might be our unawareness of the fact that we are not so intelligent nation. He believes that we, Iranians, have a comprehensive “Illusion of the high national intelligence “that make us ignorant of the unfavorable realities of our music and consequently no searching for the remedy is taking place. His point of view brings to the mind a patient who thinks he is healthy, therefore delays the treatment and finally is killed by the disease. The author also refers to the national difficulties which gradually will lower the national intelligence score such as the increased rate of the immigration and brain drain, low quality of the nutrition, incompetence of the education system and etc and predicts that the condition of the music of Iran might deteriorate in the future because of the mentioned illusion of its great status.

Henry Cowell: “Persian Set”

Persian Set: Four Movements for chamber orchestra: Moderato; Allegretto; Lento; Rondo

Henry Cowell, one of the most innovative American composers of the 20th century, was born in 1897. Cowell and his wife visited Iran in 1956 and stayed there the whole winter, upon the invitation by the Iranian Royal Family, when he composed his album “Persian Set” in four movements for chamber orchestra. His composition is expressive of the characteristic quality of the Persian or the Iranian music.

Illusion or Ingenuity?

Mohsen Renani in the preface of his book entitled “The Political Economy of nuclear conflict; an introduction to traversing the civilizations” writes:

Developments in Iranian Music Since Qajar Era (III)

Developments in Composing

Along with developments in the Iranian instruments, composition of the Iranian pieces developed as well. As a matter of fact, the developments of the two, mutually affected each other. In other words, instrumental developments led to developments in composition and vice versa.

“Guitar Memories” Released

The album “Guitar Memories” consists of the performance of baroque to recent era masterpieces, by Mehrdad Mahdavi, and is published by Tanin-e Honar Publication.

In this album there are pieces composed and arranged by artists such as: Sylvius Leopold Weiss, Johann Anton Logy, Fernando Sor, Yuquijiro Yocoh, Leo Brouwer.